America at 250: Still Worth Celebrating
America at 250: Tocqueville and World Cup visitors remind us why the United States remains worth celebrating.
As America approaches the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, the timing of the World Cup feels almost providential. The world is coming here — not only to watch matches in our stadiums, but to experience the country as it is lived.
Visitors are discovering the big things, like the size of the country, the energy of our cities, the scale of our roads, stores, portions, stadiums, and crowds. But they are also noticing smaller things Americans often take for granted: a stranger willing to give directions, a server who keeps refilling a glass, a clerk who makes conversation, a family that welcomes someone from another country as though hospitality were the most natural thing in the world.
Sometimes visitors see what residents have stopped seeing.
That was true nearly two centuries ago when Alexis de Tocqueville arrived in the United States in 1831. The young Frenchman came to study America’s prison system, but what he encountered became the subject of one of the most famous works ever written about this country, Democracy in America.
Tocqueville did not visit a settled, polished, ancient nation. He visited a young republic still pushing westward, still testing the meaning of democratic self-government, still full of contradictions. He wanted to understand why liberty had taken root here in a way that seemed different from what he knew in Europe.
He did not admire America because he thought it was innocent. Tocqueville was not blind to the moral failures already present in the American story. He saw slavery. He saw the mistreatment of Native Americans. He saw the dangers of majority opinion, materialism, restlessness, and democratic pride.
But he also saw habits that helped explain the strength of the young republic.
Americans formed churches, charities, schools, businesses, committees, and local associations. They did not assume every problem had to be solved by a distant authority. They argued, organized, volunteered, built, repaired, and started again. Tocqueville famously observed that “Americans of all ages, all conditions, all minds constantly unite.”
That habit of association impressed him because it revealed something deeper than politics. Democracy in America was more than a form of government. It was a way of life practiced close to home.
It was practiced in town meetings, congregations, homes, shops, schools, and neighborhoods. Americans exercised self-government by doing ordinary things together: raising money, founding institutions, caring for the poor, building communities, and persuading one another.
That remains one of the best things about this country.
It is tempting to measure America by Washington, D.C., cable news, social media, or the ugliness of our political arguments. Those things are real enough, and they are exhausting. They exhaust me. But they are not who we are. They are the best measure of the country.
The America Tocqueville noticed was found in the habits of citizens who believed they had a responsibility to one another and to the communities where God had placed them. It was found in people who did not wait to be commanded before they acted.
That spirit has never disappeared. It shows up when neighbors clean up after a storm. It shows up when churches feed the hungry, volunteers coach children, veterans serve in civic groups, business owners invest in their towns, and families open their homes. It shows up when an international visitor gets lost and an American stops long enough to help.
To celebrate that does not require us to whitewash our history. No honest account of America can skip over slavery, racial injustice, broken treaties, legalized segregation, or the many ways we have failed to live up to the truths we proclaimed. The Declaration announced that all men are created equal, but the country that Tocqueville visited declared it did not yet live as though it fully believed it.
That contradiction is a stain on our history, and it is painful.
Yet the words of the Declaration did not stay trapped in 1776. They became a standard by which America could be judged. They gave later generations language to confront the nation’s sins and demand that America live up to its own creed.
Abolitionists appealed to those words. Civil rights leaders appealed to those words. Generations of Americans who were denied the full promise of liberty used the nation’s founding principles to expose the gap between our ideals and our conduct.
That is one reason America is still worth celebrating at 250.
Not because we have always been righteous. We have not. Not because our history is perfect. It is not. Not because our politics are healthy. Too often, they are not.
America is worth celebrating because the promise declared in 1776 has continued to call the country upward, even when the country resisted that call. Our founding principles have often been better than our national performance, but they have also given us a way to correct course and begin again.
There is something deeply hopeful about that.
The same country that tolerated grave injustice also produced men and women who challenged it in the name of the country’s own ideals. The same nation that has often fallen short has also preserved a political and cultural inheritance that allows citizens to speak, worship, assemble, publish, protest, persuade, build, and reform.
That inheritance should never be taken for granted.
Many people around the world know what it is to live under governments that fear free speech, restrict worship, punish dissent, crush enterprise, or treat ordinary citizens as subjects rather than responsible people. America is not the only free country, and we should be grateful for our friends and allies who share many of these blessings. But the United States has long stood as a symbol of ordered liberty, and symbols do not become powerful by accident.
They become powerful because people can see something true in them.
That may be part of what international visitors are seeing now. They are not encountering a perfect country. They are encountering a large, noisy, imperfect, generous country where strangers still talk to one another, where people from different backgrounds can cheer side by side, where churches and charities serve without asking permission from the state, and where ordinary citizens still carry a sense that problems are not only someone else’s responsibility.
At 250, America does not need a brittle patriotism that denies what is broken. We need a deeper patriotism — honest enough to name our failures, grateful enough to cherish our blessings, and serious enough to preserve what is good for those who come after us.
A mature love of country can tell the truth about sin and still give thanks for blessings. It can grieve what was wicked, honor those who labored for justice, and still recognize that the American experiment has given the world something rare and precious.
The world is visiting America again. Maybe, through their eyes, we can see her more clearly.
Our history is not perfect. Our politics are often exhausting. Our national life can be loud, divided, and restless. But this country is still generous. Still free. Still capable of correction. Still filled with people who serve their neighbors, welcome strangers, worship freely, build organizations, start businesses, raise families, and try again after failure.
Two hundred fifty years after the Declaration of Independence was signed, America is still worth celebrating. And in that I rejoice.
If you like what you read here, I hope you’ll subscribe (if you haven't already) and join me for more reflections on faith, culture, politics, media, and public policy.